Phinney Estate Law
Follow Us or Like Us
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Profile of Jamie Clausen
    • Profile of Michael Ballnik
    • Holistic Approach
  • Practice Areas
    • Estate Planning & Disability Planning
    • Probate & Trust Administration
    • Guardianship & Elder Law
    • Mediation & Conflict Coaching
  • Blog
  • Fee Schedule
  • Free Classes
  • Client Reviews
  • Contact Us

Case Law Update: Witt v. Estate of Young

5/15/2012

34 Comments

 
Picture
On May 8, 2012 the Washington State Court of Appeals, Division II issued a new published opinion, Witt v. Estate of Young, which held that claims for quasi-community property by partners of the deceased who were in intimate and committed relationship are not subject to the creditor claims time limits and can be brought, most properly as a challenge to the inventory anytime until the probate is closed. 

In the Witt case, the deceased's long time partner filed a creditor's claim in her late partner's probate holding that all the property was quasi-community property and therefore should go to her.  The Personal Representative of the Estate denied the claim with a notice that any challenge to the denial must be made in 30 days.  More than 30 days late, Witt filed a complaint against the Estate in Superior Court for Partition of real and personal property.  The Estate moved for Summary Judgment to have the complaint dismissed on the basis that she had missed the thirty day window for making a challenge to the denial of her creditors' claim. The trial court declined to dismiss the action and the Estate appealed.

The Court of Appeals made on factual determination of whether the property in question would be covered by the quasi-community property rules that allow a court to treat property earned by either party during an intimate and committed relationship as analogous to community property earned during a marriage.  It left that question to the trial court.  But it did find that such a claim is really a challenge to the inventory of the Estate and not a claim for debt owed by the decedent and so isn't a creditor's claim and isn't subject to the creditor's claim time limits.  The court acknowledged that Witt had initially brought a creditors claim but found that her having done so did not preclude from bringing a more proper claim at a later date.  The court also went out of its way to make it clear that such a claim would need to be brought before the probate was closed or it would be barred.

The case provides some helpful guidance to both non-married partners who fail to do proper estate plans and personal representatives of their partner's estates about how these claims should be brought and the timelines that govern them.  This was important because while the court has been consistent and often generous in awarding these claims on an equitable basis they have come before the court in a variety of manners leaving practitioner frequently perplexed about how to properly introduce such a claim and proper way to accept or reject such claims.   As a practical matter, by channeling these claims in to the TEDRA process for challenging inventories the court has also created more generous timelines and enhanced incentives for resolving these disputes through alternative dispute resolution presumably with the hope of having more of these heavily fact intensive cases settled by the parties rather than litigated through the courts.  It is also an important reminder to personal representative who are administering estates were such a claim is possible not to let estates linger open longer than necessary as it will increase the time that these challenges can be brought and to be very careful about making any preliminary distributions before closing the estate where any possible claim could be made by an unmarried partner. 

Perhaps its best warning is that couples who are in long term, committed relationships are really best served and best taken care by careful planning before death, ideally including powers of attorney, co-habitation agreements, and wills that spell out what the plan is with regard to the creation of quasi-community property, who should be in charge of crucial life choices, and where assets should flow at death.

If you have lost a partner and want to better understand your possible rights to quasi-community property, or managing an estate that might be subject to such a claim, or are in an non-married committed relationship and want to plan to avoid this kind of potentially ugly and expensive mess at your death, please contact us to schedule a free half hour consultation at info@phinneyestatelaw.com or (206)459-1908.

34 Comments
visit here link
6/2/2013 09:12:14 pm

Thanks for the useful advice! I think similar cases happen with many couples! It is a result of the absence of proper planning! Such legal things should not be postponed to perform when we get old or at the time of death!

Reply
Adult Animal onesies link
10/7/2013 10:09:50 pm

Your article is very exciting and informational. I am trying to decide on a career move and this has helped me with one aspect. Thank you so much!

Reply
bruce hoover link
10/8/2013 12:40:06 am

This topic is something that I have been looking into for a while now and your insight is exceptional. Thanks for sharing this information.

Reply
Internet Marketing Consultation link
7/8/2013 11:34:03 pm

I am very much impressed from your post.It has amazing information.I learned lot of new things which explores my knowledge in various developments.So i must appreciate your efforts on posting these information.

Reply
SparksDUIAttorney link
7/21/2013 10:38:55 pm

I think such cases should be repeated with some differences. Because this occurs a new change in our law or some enhancement in policies. Good post.

Reply
atlanta family lawyer link
10/5/2013 12:57:16 am

I would like to thank you for your nicely written post, its informative and your writing style encouraged me to read it till end. Thanks

Reply
Try This Website link
9/16/2013 10:50:32 pm

I was completely unaware of the information which you have shared regarding Law. Great details shared indeed.

Reply
Marcus B. link
9/25/2013 07:05:34 am

This was an excellent post. It has some valuable info on this topic. Thank you for compiling it into an easy to read and well written post.

Reply
Luther Wilson link
10/4/2013 05:10:31 am

Not long ago i observed your site nevertheless get substantial an answer to this specific to hold in. Keep up the nice carry out, their particular nearly impossible to get beneficial people. We've combined with each of our faves.

Reply
writing service link
11/19/2013 09:28:47 pm

There are thousands of people who are providing writing service to students but its your observation that enables you to hire the one who is eficient and have good reputation.

Reply
Madeline link
1/17/2014 01:05:17 am

Great remarkable issues here. Im very glad to look your post. Thanks a lot and i am looking ahead to touch you. Will you kindly drop me a e-mail?

Reply
Healthy body INC link
5/10/2014 03:29:58 am

This was an excellent post. It has some valuable info on this topic. Thank you for compiling it into an easy to read and well written post.

Reply
Digital stamps link
5/12/2014 04:33:41 pm

I really enjoyed the quality information you offer to your visitors for this blog. I will bookmark this page for my future reference. Thanks!

Reply
y9 link
9/11/2014 05:34:13 pm

I love to read this type of material Good and attractive information I take from it..Thank you for posting such a good article.

Reply
Visit my Page link
10/9/2014 04:24:39 pm

This was an excellent post. It has some valuable info on this topic. Thank you for compiling it into an easy to read and well written post.

Reply
writing service link
4/27/2015 04:29:23 pm

It's good to be aware of various laws as it can always help.

Reply
college coursework help link
6/5/2015 02:50:23 pm

Interesting post for any person who wants to broaden their knowledge.

Reply
Jelly gamat gold g link
6/29/2015 12:40:54 am

Your Post has a lot of great information and it has really helped me alot. Excellent post and wonderful blog, I really like this type of interesting articles keep it up

Reply
essays link
7/22/2015 05:01:13 pm

I didn't know about this law. Thanks for the information.

Reply
live roulette link
9/27/2016 05:36:06 am

It is very import pots are display in this website that to see this website and you can specify the name, address for the particular job.

Reply
live roulette link
9/27/2016 05:36:55 am

I honestly thinking this website am providing the great info. This website is display the number of job opening that to using the nice info in this website. Thank you very much for display the nice info.

Reply
bingo cards link
9/29/2016 10:03:36 pm

Thanks a lot for providing the nice info in this blog and using the great technology in this blog.

Reply
gambling brand link
9/29/2016 10:05:11 pm

This is really superb info is visible in this blog and sharing the nice technology in this website.

Reply
poker games link
9/29/2016 10:06:08 pm

I am really great technology in this blog and sharing the nice services in this blog and the nice services in this blog.

Reply
online sports link
9/29/2016 10:07:27 pm

This is providing the wonderful technology is visible in this blog and using the nice services in this blog. Thanks a lot for providing the nice services in this blog.

Reply
bluecasinos link
10/1/2016 12:16:48 am

This is really nice services in this blog and utilizes the great technology in this website.

Reply
casino dailytimes link
10/1/2016 12:17:30 am

This is very much satisfied by the nice info is visible in this blog and sharing the nice approach is visible in this blog

Reply
casinogame online link
10/1/2016 12:18:17 am

I had really admired for the nice services in this blog

Reply
casino online link
10/2/2016 12:04:36 am

Amazing info is visible in this blog that to using the great technology in this website.

Reply
betting sites link
10/2/2016 12:07:02 am

Thanks a lot for providing the great info is visible in this blog and using the great technology.

Reply
free pokers link
10/2/2016 12:08:39 am

Great articles are visible in this blog that to wonderful technology is visible in this blog.

Reply
upload to instagram link
11/11/2017 02:15:11 am

I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page. Among the lots of comments on your articles

Reply
instagram online web viewer link
11/11/2017 03:04:35 am

You have really shared a informative and interesting blog post thanks for sharing

Reply
Denver Divorce Lawyer link
1/29/2018 06:06:26 am

Wow such a good post,! You have really shared a informative and interesting blog post thanks for sharing. Some people completely unaware of the information which you have shared regarding Law. so everybody should choose a good family lawyer for our better family solution.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    PEL Blog

    This Blog is written by Seattle Attorneys Jamie Clausen & Michael Ballnik.
    It is made available for educational purposes only. Its purpose is to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. Reading this blog does not create an attorney client relationship between you and Phinney Estate Law. Because each individual and family is unique, the Blog should not be used as a substitute for legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.

    Archives

    March 2022
    April 2020
    January 2020
    April 2018
    December 2017
    October 2017
    March 2016
    November 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    January 2012
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011

    Categories

    All
    Abatement
    Admemption
    Administrator
    Advance Health Care Directive
    Collaborative Law
    Community
    Community Classes
    Debt
    Disability Planning
    Discounts
    Downsizing
    End Of Life Planning
    Estate Planning
    Events
    Guardianship
    Health Care Agent
    Health Care Planning
    Holistic Law
    Immigration
    Informed Consent
    Intestate Administration
    Last Will And Testament
    Legacy
    Legacy Planning
    Legacy Statement
    Lgbt
    Living Will
    Mediation
    Organ Donation
    PEPS
    Posthumous Heirs
    Power Of Attorney
    Probate
    Probate Litigation
    Quasi-community Property
    Science Alerts
    Slayer Rule
    Social Security
    Tax
    Trust Administration
    Undue Influence
    Unmarried Partners
    Will Contest
    Word Of The Week

    RSS Feed